NYC Ticket Odds

Got a street cleaning ticket on a Prospect Heights pilot street? It may already be void

Short answer: if you were ticketed on a pilot street on a day that is not that block's designated enforcement day, the city has acknowledged those $65 tickets were issued in error. From August 3 through September 25, 2026, twelve Prospect Heights, Brooklyn street segments are under a once-a-week alternate side parking pilot: the posted signs stay the same, but street-cleaning tickets may only be issued on each block's designated day (a Thursday or Friday). The NYPD says the mistaken week-one tickets "were issued in error and have already been voided" — so first check your ticket's status; if it still shows as due, dispute it within 30 days. Facts on this page were checked on August 8, 2026.

Generate my free appeal letterFree while in public beta — no signup, no credit card.

How the once-a-week pilot works

The pilot is a joint project of the Department of Sanitation and Council Member Crystal Hudson's office. From Monday, August 3 through Friday, September 25, 2026, on twelve participating Prospect Heights street segments:

  • Street sweeping and ASP enforcement happen once a week on each block's designated day — a Thursday or Friday, listed segment by segment on the official pilot page.
  • The posted signs do not change. A sign may still show two or more weekly ASP windows, but during the pilot only the designated day is enforced on participating blocks.
  • On non-designated days, no ASP ticket should be issued on a pilot street — even though the posted sign says otherwise. That mismatch between sign and rule is exactly what caused the first-week mistakes.

Check the official pilot page for the exact list of participating segments and each block's designated day — don't rely on the posted sign during the pilot window.

What went wrong in week one (Aug 3–4, 2026)

On the pilot's first two days, traffic enforcement agents who had not been told about the new schedule ticketed — and in some cases stickered — dozens of legally parked cars on pilot streets (NY Post, August 6, 2026; Hoodline, August 7, 2026).

  • The NYPD's statement (via the NY Post): "These summonses were issued in error and have already been voided. We will ensure that the Department of Sanitation creates a formal process for notifying the NYPD about any requests for changes to longstanding parking rules."
  • Council Member Hudson's office said it received about a dozen complaints, and that "the City has assured us that any summonses issued on non-designated enforcement days will be dismissed."

The takeaway: the city is on record, twice, that non-designated-day tickets on pilot streets are invalid. That is an unusually strong position to dispute from — if your ticket wasn't already voided.

Got a $65 ticket on a pilot street? Do this

  • 1. Confirm your block and its designated day. Find your street segment on the official pilot page and note its designated enforcement day. If your ticket's violation date is that day, the ticket is a normal street cleaning ticket — the pilot doesn't help you, but the usual defenses might.
  • 2. Check the ticket's status by summons number or plate — the first-week batch was voided by the city, so yours may already show as dismissed or simply not appear. Our free lookup guide shows how; note tickets can take a few days to appear in the system.
  • 3. If it still shows as due, dispute it within 30 days. State that the summons was issued on a participating pilot street on a non-designated enforcement day, cite the official pilot announcement (council.nyc.gov/crystal-hudson/asppilot/) and the violation date, and mention the NYPD's public acknowledgment that such summonses were issued in error. Photos of your ticket and the street sign help.
  • 4. Keep the evidence. Photograph the ticket, the sticker if you got one, and the posted sign before removing anything.

If your facts fit, our free letter generator can draft the dispute statement from what you tell it — free, no signup.

Also that week: the green stickers returned citywide

In the same week the pilot launched, DSNY resumed placing bright green warning stickers on cars that block street sweepers citywide — a separate change under Int 0092-2026, which repealed the 2012 sticker ban. Some mistakenly ticketed pilot-street cars were stickered too. The sticker itself adds no extra fine; it accompanies the standard $65 summons. See our full 2026 sticker guide for that story.

Is a street cleaning ticket worth fighting in general?

Yes, often — even outside the pilot. Across 1,784,003 decided street cleaning hearings in NYC Open Data, 25.8% ended not guilty and another 12.9% ended with a reduced fine. These are historical group statistics, not a prediction for any single case — but they show these tickets are far from unbeatable. See the street cleaning stats page and the full street cleaning guide for the defenses that historically work.

Frequently asked questions

I got a ticket on a Prospect Heights pilot street on the wrong day. Do I have to pay?

If the ticket was issued between Aug 3 and Sep 25, 2026, on a participating pilot street on a day other than that block's designated enforcement day, the city has said such summonses were issued in error — the first-week batch was voided, and the Council Member's office says the city assured them any non-designated-day summonses will be dismissed. Check the ticket's status first; if it still shows as due, dispute it within 30 days citing the official pilot announcement.

My car got a green sticker too — is that a separate fine?

No. The green DSNY sticker is an enforcement and deterrence measure that accompanies the standard $65 street cleaning summons; it adds no extra charge. If the underlying summons was issued in error under the pilot, dispute the summons — and photograph the sticker and signs before removing anything.

Which streets are in the pilot, and what are the designated days?

Twelve Prospect Heights, Brooklyn street segments participate, each with a designated enforcement day (a Thursday or Friday). The authoritative segment-by-segment list is on the official pilot page at council.nyc.gov/crystal-hudson/asppilot/ — check it rather than relying on the posted signs, which are unchanged during the pilot.

Will the once-a-week ASP pilot expand to other neighborhoods?

Possibly. DSNY has said community boards elsewhere can express interest in similar pilots, and press coverage describes the Prospect Heights program as a test case. Nothing beyond the Aug 3 – Sep 25, 2026 Prospect Heights pilot had been announced as of August 8, 2026.

What happens after September 25, 2026?

When the pilot window ends on September 25, 2026, the posted alternate side parking signs — which never changed — are enforced as written again, unless the city announces an extension or a permanent rule change. Check the official pilot page for updates before relying on the once-a-week schedule after that date.

Get a drafted statement — free for a limited time

Average fine for this violation: $58 — if dismissed, you could save $58. The draft is currently free.

Our tool drafts a dispute statement for your specific ticket, grounded in the defense categories most often raised in successful hearings for this violation type. You review and edit it, then submit it yourself on the official NYC site. Normally $19 — free for a limited time.

See a sample letter →

Limit: 2 free drafts per day per person.

We’re not a law firm and this isn’t legal advice — you review and file everything yourself, free, on the official NYC site.

Related guides

Official NYC.gov resource

Official NYC dispute brochure in your language

The NYC Department of Finance publishes its official “Disputing Your Parking Summons” brochure in 10 languages.

Also available in:

NYC Ticket Odds is not a law firm and this guide is not legal advice. It summarizes publicly available NYC Department of Finance procedures and public hearing data. Rules can change — always confirm details on nyc.gov. Historical statistics do not predict or guarantee the outcome of any individual case.

Free appeal letter →

Free · no signup · ~5 minutes